Best Recordings of 2004
Methods—First of all, there’s nothing I don’t like on this list, all the way down to Los Lobos. As people who make such lists often say, things could be placed differently on different days. As I was typing AIR at number 49, I thought that perhaps it could be higher. But if I were to be honest, I didn’t listen to it that much throughout the year. For me, that urge to listen to it figures in, and an album propelling an interest in an artist’s entire back catalog says something. I sort of group things by tens then weigh them against the things immediately around them. That way, I feel comfortable making an ordered list as opposed to the orderless ones I see here and there. Lists are subjective, but mine is best.
1. Modest Mouse—Good News for People Who Love Bad News
This would be one of those aforementioned ones that made me buy everything else by the artist. And everything else shows that this is the breakthrough album. They’ve always had a bit of a Pixies vibe but have added a Tom Wa...